Long Island, known for its rich history and charming communities, is also home to chilling myths and legends that have been passed down through generations. From haunted lighthouses to cursed estates, these tales have captivated the imaginations of locals and visitors alike.

The Lady of Lake Ronkonkoma

The tale of the Lady of Lake Ronkonkoma tells of a Native American woman who tragically died in the lake after her colonial lover was forbidden to see her. Since then, it's said that the ghost of the lady claims one male victim each year.

Fire Island's Black Dog

Fire Island is famed for its beachside revelry, but did you know it's also the home of a spectral black dog? As legend has it, those who see the mysterious canine will face bad luck or even death.

The Haunting of Mount Misery

Mount Misery in Huntington is the source of countless ghost stories, perhaps due to its eerie, winding trails and dense woods. It's reputedly haunted by multiple spirits, including a spectral woman who roams the roads, according to The Atlantic.

The Cursed Katie's of Smithtown

The pub known as Katie's in Smithtown has long been rumored to be haunted. Workers and patrons report eerie experiences, from mysterious footsteps to objects moving on their own. According to Patch, it was even investigated by the Ghost Adventures team!

Whether you believe in the supernatural or not, these stories give a fascinating insight into Long Island's history and culture. They might even give you a chill down your spine next time you're out exploring!